Lawmaker wants to stop red light cameras

February 26th, 2010 by – All eyes are looking toward Florida lawmakers to determine whether red light cameras will be accepted statewide as one Spring Hill state representative files a bill opposing their use.

State Rep. Robert Schenck, R-Spring Hill, announced Thursday his filing of a bill that would forbid local governments from enforcing traffic laws using red light cameras.

In a press release Thursday, Schenck reiterated his previous stance against governments using red light cameras as a revenue source — taking aim at red light camera programs in Brooksville and other cities.

As of the first of the year, Schenck said Brooksville has issued more than 5,000 tickets using the cameras. He said the city and others across the state use the cameras to increase revenue in light of falling property values.

“I do not believe it is right for local governments to use cameras as a means to increase falling revenue under the guise of public safety,” Schenck said. “I believe this is nothing more than a hidden tax on my constituents and to the citizens of the state of Florida.”

Schenck said Thursday he believes the issue will be strongly debated in the House — particularly since it’s rare to have two bills at odds on an issue.

Earlier this year, a Senate and House bill were filed that would allow for red light camera initiatives to be used statewide — a measure similar to Brooksville’s existing red light ordinance.

The difference is, if approved, the bills would increase ticket costs from $125 to $150 and the state would get a $75 cut, with $55 going to the state’s general fund and $20 to the Department of Health Administrative Trust Fund.

The remaining $75 would go to the municipality where the infraction occurred.
Schenck has voiced opposition to those bills as well because they would be used as a revenue source to the state.

Brooksville Police Chief George Turner said he believes the measure in favor of using red light cameras will pass this year and red light cameras will eventually be used throughout the state.
For Brooksville, he said the cameras have been a safety measure that has helped decrease traffic accidents in the city by 35 percent — from 299 in 2008 to 193 in 2009, a difference of 106 accidents.

“You never really know what the Legislature is going to do,” Turner said. “But I think there’s a majority of people in favor of these red light bills. Unlike last year, I think they’ll pass. People like them because they make the roads safer.”

Schenck’s filing of his bill follows a ruling from a Miami-Dade circuit judge this week who stated that the city of Aventura couldn’t use the cameras to enforce traffic laws.

Scott Dudley, an advocate with the Florida League of Cities and a proponent of the red light cameras, said those on both sides of the issue are waiting to hear the written ruling from the judge in the case.
However, he said the only thing for certain is that state lawmakers will have to clarify the issue.

“(The ruling) gives some indication of the judicial temperament toward the legal arguments for and against red light cameras,” Dudley said. “And it signals the need for cities to urge their legislators to support legislation that will unequivocally legitimize any existing red light traffic enforcement devices already in place and support existing home rule authority of cities to regulate local activity in this area.”

2 Responses

  1. Walter Latham

    Are the tickets legal or not….In Adventura they have been stricken – Supreme Court in Minnesota Struck down the camera
    issue as unconstitutional…. Where does Brooksville and Hernando County stand?

  2. Trust Justice

    No Chief Dodobrain, the majority of the people are NOT in favor of the red light cameras. You can’t even enforce your own ordinance correctly – why don’t you read it some time and see if you can issue the “tickets” in accordance with YOUR OWN ORDINANCE!

    What is really a joke is that if you contest the ticket “and win” you still have to pay FIFTY DOLLARS! This is nothing more than RIPPING PEOPLE OFF. If you contest the ticket “and lose” you not only pay the ticket, but you have to pay AN ADDITIONAL FIFTY DOLLARS! The henchmen that run Brooksville really thought of everything when they wrote this little gem of an ordinance. I hope they choke on the money, and rot in hell. They are just stealing from the people they claim to serve.

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment. You are free to voice your opinion but please keep it clean. Any comments using profanity will be rejected.